MyBestMattress is an independent, personal project. All the content on this website is free to use.
You can help keep the site free & unbiased by donating. Your support is highly appreciated!

Tuft and Needle VS Casper: a woman sleeping in a bed.

If you’re having a hard time picking one bed out of the Tuft and Needle VS Casper duel, then you’ve come to the right place. While it can get pretty hectic - trying to pick out one mattress out of two great options -, it doesn’t have to be that way! All you need is a proper, side-by-side comparison - that’s exactly what you’ll find in this article.

CASPER TUFT AND NEEDLE

Overall Score

8.0
7.0

Type

Memory Foam Memory Foam

Best Sleeping Position

All All

Verdict

Eco-Friendly, Medium-Firm, 100-Nights Sleep Trial Great for quality of sleep. Good motion isolation.
See TOP10 Brands
Read Review
See TOP10 Brands
Read Review

Table: Tuft and Needle and Casper comparison short introduction

While both of the beds in this Casper mattresses VS Tuft and Needle comparison have one, specific feature in common, that does not mean that they’re the same - far from it! That said, both of these companies make great products that will suit different people - it’s all a matter of your personal preferences, want and needs.

If you’d like to see everything that we’ll talk about in a simple, easy-to-read table, you can access it here. With that, however, let’s move and talk about a few essential mattress features, first.

 Tuft and Needle VS Casper: The Foundation

Before we go on and jump into the Tuft and Needle VS Casper comparison, we need to figure out the criteria by which each of these mattresses are going to be evaluated.

Different from what you might be thinking, that’s not necessarily an easy task to accomplish.

That said, while different people tend to have very different opinions about what is “essential” and what is “secondary”, the features that are going to have an effect on your sleep time and quality should always be placed on top.

CASPER TUFT AND NEEDLE

Durability

Good Good

Edge Support

Good Poor

Cooling

Average Good

Motion Isolation

Average Good

Noise Isolation

Good Good

Responsiveness

Good Poor

Off-gassing

|
|
|
none
moderate
heavy
|
|
|
none
moderate
heavy

Bounciness

Average Good

Suitable for sex

Average Poor

Table: Tuft and Needle and Casper features and benefits

Glancing at the table above, you can see most of the important features associated with a well-made, top-tier mattress. That being said, in this Casper Mattress VS Tuft and Needle article, we’ll be talking about five big features - durability, firmness, motion isolation, cooling and bounciness.

  • Durability. The durability of your mattress depends on many different things - what are the materials used in its construction? Was it built well? Was it designed with proper criteria in mind? These and many more questions will determine whether your new bed will serve you for a year or ten years - Tuft and Needle VS Casper comparison are no different.
  • Firmness. On one hand, firmness is completely preferential - some people like to sleep on a soft surface, while others prefer firm mattresses - and that’s perfectly fine! However, on the other hand, you should think about your health, too - since medium-firm mattresses are considered to be better for your lower back health, this is the type you should be seeking out the most.
  • Motion isolation. A (quote, unquote) “good” mattress is going to absorb motion rather well. It doesn’t even matter what type of motion we’re talking about, in the first place - pillow fights, playing with your pets, sex - you name it! Also, no one wants to feel every single movement that their partner makes throughout the night - this is where motion isolation is super-important!
  • Cooling. Almost all of the top-tier beds in the industry are going to have some sort of a cooling technology implemented into their design. Cooling covers and special, gel-infused foam are just a couple of examples - you would be surprised at how creative some companies can be! Either way, temperature neutrality is important - always check for this feature, whether in a Tuft and Needle VS Casper comparison, or else!
  • Bounciness. Bouncy mattresses are most useful for couples. A responsive and bouncy bed can help you improve your sex life by being, well… Bouncy. If you’re trying to participate in a Netflix and chill kind of activity, and keep on sinking down into the mattress, that’s usually a sign that something’s not quite right.

Naturally, there are always going to be more features that you should pay attention to. However, whether it’s a Casper Essential VS Tuft and Needle, Casper VS Purple or any other “VS” article, these five criteria should always primarily be on your mind.

Tuft and Needle VS Casper: The Comparison

Now, moving on to the actual Tuft and Needle VS Casper comparison, let’s conduct it in the same order as the previous list - starting from the durability of each of the beds.

Durability

Durability refers to your mattress staying in-tact and not breaking apart during the first year of you sleeping on it.

While this isn’t a problem when it comes to the Tuft and Needle VS Casper comparison, you would be surprised just how many beds like this there are in the market.

Tuft and Needle VS Casper: Casper being made in Britain.

Going back to our duo in question, customers report that both Tuft and Needle and Casper mattresses are actually pretty durable, and “hold their ground” quite well. Even though Casper is comprised out of four layers while T&N has two, there should still be minimal signs of wear after a few years of sleeping on the beds, either way.

This is actually quite refreshing, since both mattresses in this Casper mattress VS Tuft and Needle comparison are made out of memory foam. While it’s a pretty popular material to build beds out of, if done incorrectly, the final product can be really prone to wear. Thankfully, though, neither of the beds in this article present such an issue.

Firmness

As mentioned earlier, whether it’s a Casper Essential VS Tuft and Needle, or any other type of a comparison, firmness is always going to be a heavily contested topic.

It actually depends on how you look at it. If you are adamant about sleeping soft, and prioritize comfort over everything else, then the choice is rather simple.

CASPER TUFT AND NEEDLE

Layer Number

4 2

Thickness (")

11 10

Firmness

5.5
|
|
|
soft
medium
firm
6.5
|
|
|
soft
medium
firm

Table: Firmness and thickness options of the Tuft and Needle and Casper mattresses

However, if you’re at least somewhat health-conscious, and are yourself experiencing back and hip pains, then a firmer mattress should be the product you set your sight on.

When it comes to this Tuft and Needle VS Casper article, however, both of the beds are on the firmer side of the spectrum. Casper is often regarded as being “medium-firm” - ideal for anyone suffering from earlier-talked-about issues. Tuft and Needle is even firmer - if you like a rather firm bed, then this mattress might suit you better.

Motion Isolation

Truth be told, Casper isn’t good at isolating motion. Many customer Casper reviews note that people can feel their partners tossing and turning during the night quite well - it’s distracting, and can really disturb your sleep cycle and render you completely tired when it’s time to wake up in the morning.

Tuft and Needle VS Casper: Tuft and Needle mattress selection.

That said, this is where Tuft and Needle prevails - the mattress seems to provide sleepers with some top-tier motion isolation qualities. In all honesty, that’s actually pretty odd, especially given that the bed is only comprised out of two layers, as opposed to Casper’s four.

Naturally, though, this is still completely preferential - if you’re someone who sleeps alone, then motion transfer isn’t even that big of a deal, in the first place.

Cooling

As discussed earlier on in the Tuft and Needle VS Casper comparison, most top-tier mattress providers in the industry are going to have some sort of a cooling technology built into their products. Some are effective, others… Not so much.

Thing is, when you’re dealing with memory foam, it can be exceptionally difficult to keep the bed cool. Memory foam, same as other types of foam, has a tendency to heat up pretty fast, and not disperse the heat away from the sleeper’s body.

Tuft and Needle VS Casper: Casper mattress promotion.

Casper does seem that have fallen victim to this “heat trap”. Customers claim that, while it’s not the hottest-sleeping bed in the world, it certainly does not sleep cool.

Our other competitor in this Tuft and Needle VS Casper duel, however, is different - multiple customer Tuft and Needle reviews note how the mattress actually sleeps relatively cool, despite its memory foam-oriented design. That’s surprising! Sure, the fact that it’s a thin mattress does have a lot to do with it, but nonetheless - pretty cool!

Bounciness

You know when you push your mattress down, and it quickly springs right back up into place? That’s basically the definition of a bouncy mattress.

Bouncy beds are ideal for anyone who likes their mattress to retain its shape, and who want to make their sexual life a whole lot easier. Casper VS Tuft and Needle reviews point out that if your bed is bouncy, it’s going to be much easier to get into the rhythm of… Well, rhythmic movements.

Tuft and Needle VS Casper: Tuft and Needle mattresses.

Some beds, however, are prone to sink you down. You might have guessed it already, but that’s mostly the case with memory foam beds - while they have their pros and benefits, bounciness definitely isn’t one of them.

Oddly enough, though, while the former competitor of this Casper mattress VS Tuft and Needle comparison is exactly like that, Casper, on the other hand, is reported to be rather bouncy! While that’s an unlikely combination (it being bouncy, yet not as firm as T&N), it’s definitely a welcome one, for sure!

Sleeping Position

While we have covered the five main features of the Tuft and Needle VS Casper comparison, I’ve left one big question out on purpose - the question of sleeping positions.

Why did I do this, you may ask? Simple - it’s a topic that deserves to be discussed separately.

You see, out of the three main sleeping positions that there are (back, stomach and side), each one has its own, specific preferences of what type of a mattress will suit it. Sure, there are universal beds - ones that are great for all types of sleepers, but in all honesty, those are pretty rare.

CASPER TUFT AND NEEDLE

Pros

  • Made of Quality Material
  • Casper is For Every Sleeper’s Needs
  • Medium-Firm Level of Support that Works for Almost Everyone
  • 100-Nights Sleep Trial
  • Durable (Confirmed by Users' Reviews)
  • Very durable
  • Isolates sound perfectly
  • Little-to-no off-gassing

Cons

  • Only One Firmness Option
  • Not so Great for Hot Sleepers
  • Lackluster edge support
  • Not the best responsiveness

Value For Money

Customer Satisfaction

Table: Tuft and Needle and Casper mattress sleeping positions

That being the case, though, you could say that we’ve hit the jackpot in this Tuft and Needle VS Casper comparison - according to multiple different customer reviews, both of these mattresses are great for all types of sleepers.

This is especially peculiar when you consider the fact that both of the mattresses in question are memory foam-based. It’s much more common for a hybrid mattress to be great for all of the different kinds of sleepers - not so much when it comes to memory foam, though!

Price

Finally, let’s address the last (but oh-so-certainly not least) point of this Tuft and Needle VS Casper comparison - pricing.

CASPER TUFT AND NEEDLE

Cali King

(72" x 84")

Cali King mattress price

$1195

Cali King mattress price

$750

King

(76" x 80")

King mattress price

$1195

King mattress price

$750

Queen

(60" x 80")

Queen mattress price

$995

Queen mattress price

$595

Full

(53" x 75")

Full mattress price

$895

Full mattress price

$495

Twin XL

(38" x 80")

Twin XL mattress price

$645

Twin XL mattress price

$395

Twin

(38" x 75")

Twin mattress price

$595

Twin mattress price

$350

Latest Coupons

See All Coupons of Best Mattresses See All Coupons of Best Mattresses

Table: Pricing options for the Tuft and Needle and Casper mattresses

The pricing options for the Tuft and Needle mattress are:

Casper’s prices are, as follows:

While both mattresses can be considered more than affordable, Tuft and Needle is honestly one of the most affordable beds that you’re likely to come across!

CASPER TUFT AND NEEDLE

Trial

100 Nights 100 Nights

Warranty

10 Year 10 Year

Free Shipping

International Shipping

Table: Tuft and Needle and Casper mattress shipping, trial and warranty information

On top of some amazing prices, both mattresses of this Casper VS Tuft and Needle comparison offer 100-night sleep trials, 10-year guarantees and free shipping. Casper does take it a step further and add international shipping - that’s great!

Conclusions

So, with this Tuft and Needle VS Casper comparison article coming to an end, only one question remains - which of the two beds is better?

Truth be told, whether it’s a Casper Essential VS Tuft and Needle, or any other type of a mattress comparison article, the general rule stays the same - given that both of the products analyzed above are considered top-tier, you should choose in accordance to your own, personal preferences.

Casper is going to be better for anyone who likes to sleep cool, and who doesn’t sleep alone. The bed is great at isolating motion, and is responsive especially when compared to Tuft and Needle. That said, it’s also quite a bit more expensive.

Tuft and Needle, on the other hand, is super-affordable, durable and silent. It’s not at all bouncy, and is relatively firm, but that’s not too surprising, given the bed’s two-layer design.

Both beds of this Casper VS Tuft and Needle comparison offer free shipping within the US, both have 10-year warranties and 100-night sleep trials in place. Casper does also ship internationally, though.

If, after reading this article, you’ve decided that neither of the two mattresses suit your wants and needs, do make sure to check out our list of the best mattresses of the year, in general. Also, if you would like to see the full technical specifications of both Casper and Tuft and Needle side-by-side, you can find them here.

Casper Deal Active Right Now:

FAQ

Which of the two Tuft and Needle VS Casper mattresses is better?

In general, Casper is going to be better for anyone who can afford a bit of a more expensive mattress that has strong edge support, good bounciness and is somewhat bouncy. Tuft and Needle should fit people who don't sleep alone and appreciate cooler-sleeping mattresses.

Are memory foam mattresses good, in general?

To put it short - yes, memory foam mattresses are some of the more popular types of beds in the industry. While the might have durability issues, and sleep somewhat hot, they are great at molding to the sleeper's body and keeping your spine aligned.

What is a memory foam mattress?

Memory foam mattresses are created mostly from polyurethane and have additional chemicals added that increase its viscosity and density. It’s also often called “viscoelastic polyurethane foam”. In order to create the air movement and let your body “breath” while you sleep, it has open foam bubbles. Memory foam mattresses are created in a way to adapt to your body curves and to also recover their original shape after you get up. Therefore, this kind of top mattresses offer you the feeling as if is created specifically for you.

Do top rated mattresses offer a money-back guarantee? Is there a catch?

All of the top mattress brands offer a money-back guarantee. The free trial usually starts from 90 to 100 nights, and if you don’t like the mattress, you can simply give it back. The majority of best mattress providers will not only give your money back but will also come to get it for free. If the mattress provider is reputable, there won’t be any catch - everyone understands that you have to try the mattress before knowing if it fits you.

What is off-gassing? Is it poisonous?

Off-gassing refers to the odor which comes from a new mattress. It’s the process that happens when volatile organic chemicals (VOCs) leak out of the mattress foam into the air. Those chemicals include both human-made and natural components, including formaldehyde, chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs), benzene, trichloroethane, and perfluorocarbons. Top rated mattresses will have zero or very minimal off-gassing. Many of them are sent to the customer already after the off-gassing. Is it dangerous, though? Even though the smell can be unpleasant, there’s usually only a very small amount of chemicals that can do no harm to your health.

How long do top rated mattresses serve?

The durability of a mattress depends on the provider and the quality of the materials used. Usually, you get a 10-year warranty, which will be valid in case of any defects. Normally, mattresses will serve you from 7 to 10 years, or even longer. Thus, when you buy the best mattress, you should take it as a long-term investment.