MyBestMattress is an independent, personal project. All the content on this website is free to use.
You can help keep the site free & unbiased by donating. Your support is highly appreciated!

Money Back Guarantee
Our score
User Rating

(621 User Reviews)


(726 User Reviews)


(382 User Reviews)


(424 User Reviews)


(261 User Reviews)


(131 User Reviews)

Most Popular
828 Reviews
Editor's Choice
621 Reviews
726 Reviews
424 Reviews
261 Reviews
131 Reviews

Your quality of sleep can is usually determined by a variety of different factors - this is true no matter who you are (a nigh shift worker, a pregnant woman[1], no matter your race or ethnicity, etc). While there are many such factors, the majority of them are in your control. But how do the best down alternative comforters fit into this picture?

Simple - these comforters can aid your quality of sleep, in more ways than one. It does, however, depend on the actual choice of the product - while some are great and worth your attention, others can leave a lot to be desired.

Today, however, we’ll be looking at some customer down alternative comforter reviews that talk about the better options. Our list will include the following:

Here is The Best Saatva Offer I Found:

Best Down Alternative Comforter: What to Look For

Before we get to the actual list of the down alternative comforters, allow me to be the first one to say - while comforters aren’t as popular as some blankets or mattress sheets (when it comes to the most commonly bought sleep products, that is), they can still be superb, if you pick the right one.

How should you do that, you may ask? Well, if you’re reading this article, you’ve already got it narrowed down pretty well - you’re looking for a down alternative product, as opposed to one that’s actually filled with real down.

Having said that, you should also make sure to pay close attention to the entirety of the construction of the product - the materials used, it’s durability (longevity), cleaning intricacies, and so on. All of these factors can make a product great, but they can alsoshow that the comforter is going to be little more than a headache, too.

Also, the “alternative” part is somewhat important, too. Some down alternatives are going to feel just like the real thing - others will resemble cheap knock-offs. In most cases, however, the situation is pretty obvious straight from the get-go.

Best down alternative comforter: down alternative pillow.

All of that being said… Why would anyone be looking for the down alternative comforter, in the first place?

For a couple of reasons, actually. Most of the time, people need a down alternative product because of their allergies. Being allergic to goose or duck down is not an uncommon thing, whatsoever. If you want to get that one-of-a-kind softness and puffiness that down products provide, yet are allergic to the material, down alternative comforters are the way to go.

Also, the price tag. Down comforters tend to be very expensive, since most of them utilize goose down as their filling. Even the down alternative comforters, though, are going to be considerably more affordableMost of the time. It does somewhat depend on the brand and the product, but the idea still remains the same.

So - with all of that said, let us jump straight into the list of the down alternative comforters of the year.

1. Linenspa All-Season Reversible Down Alternative Comforter - High Quality, Hypoallergenic Comforter

Ranks #1 out of 7 Mattresses

Surely, Linenspa is one of the most common names that pop up when you search for the best down alternative comforters. Even more so than that, it’s actually one of the best comforters on the current market, in general!

So, what makes Linenspa’s product so appealing? Well, let’s tackle the obvious first - they are made with a down alternative filling.

The All-Season comforters are filled with microfiber that acts as the alternative to down. The cover (case) of the comforter is made from polyester - that’s actually a pretty uncommon construction! Most brands aim to go with cotton-based covers, since these offer the best breathability.

How’s the polyester option working out for Linenspa? Well, considering that it’s one of the best down alternative comforters, I’d say - pretty well! The comforter is completely hypoallergenic, and is made from truly high-quality materials.

What is the Price of the Linenspa All-Season Reversible Down Alternative Comforter?

The pricing options for the comforter in question are:

As you can probably see for yourself, pricing is definitely another huge factor that influences all of the positive customer reviews towards the product in question - the prices are amazing!

Visit Linenspa Comforter

2. KingLinen White Down Alternative Comforter - A Soft Comforter

Ranks #2 out of 7 Mattresses

Softness is usually one of the most sought-after features when people look for high-end comforters. It make perfect sense, too - these products are generally bought with coziness and comfort being the main reasons, and you can’t really get truly cozy with a rough, flat comforter.

KingLinen proves this even further - their version of the best down alternative comforter is surely one of the best examples of what a soft sleep item can do to you after a long day!

As with any other comforter on this list, KingLinen’s product is made with goose down alternative. It would appear that the company has done a pretty good job on the matter, too, since goose down is the material that is usually considered to be very soft and fluffy, and mimicking that isn’t necessarily all that easy.

What is the Price of the KingLinen White Down Alternative Comforter?

KingLinen’s prices are:

Unfortunately, there are only two sizes of the comforter available. Still, the prices are great!

Visit KingLinen Comforter

3. Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter - Very Breathable

Ranks #3 out of 7 Mattresses

If you’ve spent any time searching for the best down alternative comforters, or even some other best sleep products, in general, you’ve probably heard about Brooklinen at one point or another. The company has managed to build a very stable name for itself as being one of the industry leaders in regards to mattress accessories and other sleep products.

As you might have gathered, their down alternative comforters aren’t an exception.

One of the most commonly-referenced features of the Brooklinen comforters is breathability. Multiple customer best down alternative comforter reviews are going to tell you that you’ll have no issues with being “too hot” while sleeping with the comforter in question, since the cotton cover of the product won’t trap heat or allow it to gather up.

What is the Price of the Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter?

Brooklinen comforter’s prices are:

Yup - it surely is one of the most expensive down alternative comforters. Still, if you want a truly high-quality product, Brooklinen is bound to provide you with just that.

Visit Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter

Compare Mattresses Side by Side With Others

Did you know?

Compare Mattresses Side by Side With Others

All mattresses may look similar to you but they're NOT all the same!

Yes! Show me the Comparison Chart

4. Buffy Comforter - All-Around Well-Designed Comforter

Ranks #4 out of 7 Mattresses

Buffy offers customers one of the rarer best down alternative comforter options. You see, most comforters are great for some specific purpose - some are very soft and cozy, others - breathable.  While a comforter may exceed in multiple areas, it usually has that one, “signature” feature for which people know it.

Buffy’s product, however, is actually quite universal.

Reading through customer online best down alternative comforter reviews, it would seem that people give praise to Buffy for a variety of different reasons - comfort, softness, breathability, visual appearance, and so on. An all-around great product!

What is the Price of the Buffy Comforter?

Buffy’s comforter prices are:

While it might not be the most affordable comforter on the market, it’s definitely not the most expensive option, either.

Visit Buffy Comforter
...or read our Buffy Comforter review

5. Royal Hotel Goose Down Alternative Comforter - Egyptian Cotton-Based Cover, Easy to Clean

Ranks #5 out of 7 Mattresses

As the name likely implies, Royal Hotel is a brand that sells some luxurious, high-end products. The brand’s version of the best down alternative comforter is no different in that regard, either - Royal Hotel uses Egyptian cotton as the cover material of the comforter.

Egyptian cotton is one of the best cotton options for this type of a purpose, since it provides the highest degree of breathability and durability. Surely, you should be able to sleep with the product all throughout the year.

Also, it’s worth mentioning that the cleaning process of the comforter is also very simple and straightforward. Basically, you won’t need to use any special chemicals or some sort of a fancy cleaning method - the comforter is completely machine-washable.

What is the Price of the Royal Hotel Goose Down Alternative Comforter?

Royal Hotel prices it’s comforters like so:

The pricing options are actually very decent, concerning the quality of the product!

Visit Royal Hotel Down Alternative Comforter

6. GreyEagle Bedding Down Alternative Comforter - Very Durable, Hypoallergenic

Ranks #6 out of 7 Mattresses

GreyEagle Bedding might not be the first company that you think about when it comes to the best down alternative comforters, but it sure does deserve to be mentioned on a list like this.

One of the most notable features of GreyEagle’s comforter is that it’s exceptionally durable. The product features a double stitching design - this enables it to be very sturdy and reliable, and you shouldn’t find yourself with a needle and thread in hand, fixing up some holes.

The product is also filled with microfibers - that’s the “down alternative” part. This is great for anyone who’s allergic to down (whether it be goose down, duck down, or any other kind of this material), since it eliminates the possibility of your allergies acting up.

What is the Price of the GreyEagle Bedding Down Alternative Comforter?

The product in question is priced like so:

The unfortunate part here is that there are only a couple of sizing options of the comforter available, and they’re quite… Big. Still, the price tags are rather decent, when compared to some other options of the best down alternative comforters out there.

Visit GreyEagle Bedding Down Alternative Comforter

7. Cuddledown Damask Stripe Synthetic Fill Comforter - Warm and Durable

Ranks #7 out of 7 Mattresses

Cuddledown offers customers a soft, warm and durable option when it comes to the best down alternative comforters out there.

The softness aspect is made sure by the amount of filling - while there are multiple options to pick from, most customer reviews seem to be quite happy about the softness of the product.

As noted above, the comforter is also very warm to sleep with, and also exceeds in the area of durability. The former means that you’ll be able to feel cozy and comfortable with the comforter, while also retaining warmth in the colder seasons. The latter, however, showcases the quality aspect of the product - it being durable means that it will serve you for a long time to come, too.

What is the Price of the Cuddledown Stripe Synthetic Fill Comforter?

Cudledown’s comforter (level 1) is priced like so:

Surely, it’s a bit of a pricey option, especially when you consider that there are better-known brands that sell their versions of the best down alternative comforters for some more affordable prices.

Visit Cuddledown Down Alternative Comforter

Here is The Best Saatva Offer I Found:


It’s a pretty well-known and established fact that sleep deprivation can cause various health issues[2], both short- and long-term. There are many methods of how you can combat this problem, and the best down alternative comforters are simply some of the more underrated tools that can help you do so.

That being said, if you’re looking for ways to improve your sleep, you should always make sure to prioritize getting yourself a new mattress, above anything else (when it comes to products, that is). A new high-quality bed is going to be the best way to improve your quality of sleep, sleep-related product-wise.

Thanks for reading this article about the best down alternative comforters on the current market! I hope you’ve managed to find a product that would suit your wants and needs. Until next time!

Scientific References

1. Lavonius M, Railo H, Karlsson L, et al.: 'Maternal sleep quality during pregnancy is associated with neonatal auditory ERPs.'

2. Collet J, Ftouni S, Clough M, et al.: 'Differential Impact of Sleep Deprivation and Circadian Timing on Reflexive Versus Inhibitory Control of Attention.'

Leave your honest Best Down Alternative Comforter review

Leave your genuine opinion & help thousands of people to choose the best mattress. All reviews, either positive or negative, are accepted as long as they’re honest. We do not publish biased reviews or spam. So if you want to share your experience, opinion or give advice - the scene is yours!

Saatva comparison
Puffy comparison
Saatva comparison
Nectar comparison

Recent Best Down Alternative Comforter User Reviews

5.0/5.0 - Buffy Comforter Owner

Especially perfect for winter

This purchase was such great timing!! It's just getting to be warm enough where I can turn the heater off but not warm enough to justify turning the AC on, so this is perfectttt for this in-between weather!

Price value
Trials & Refunds
5.0/5.0 - Buffy Comforter Owner

Perfect for hot sleepers

I’m such a hot sleeper and this comforter is perfect for me! It’s also so soft and looks great when I make my bed. Can’t recommend enough

Price value
Trials & Refunds


What are the benefits of down alternative comforters over real down-filled product?

One of the biggest benefits is that the best down alternative comforters aren't going to make your allergies act up. Down is famous for invoking an allergic reaction in quite a few people, and choosing the alternative route is a great way to avoid this. Also, real down comforters are usually quite expensive - the alternatives, however, are significantly much more affordable.

How to pick the best down alternative comforter?

There are many options on the market when it comes to the best down alternative comforters. The actual best choice for yourself is going to depend on a variety of factors - the materials that you're allergic to, your budget, filling preferences, and so on. While actual down products are usually going to be much softer and luxurious, down alternatives will be more affordable, and are thus a better choice when it comes to purchasing your first comforter.

How to choose the best mattress for me?

When choosing the best mattress for yourself, there are a few important factors that you should consider. First of all, what type of mattress do you need? The most traditional mattresses are memory foam, innerspring and latex, but there are other options, too. Secondly, think about how much you can spend on a mattress, but remember it doesn’t mean that the mattress is better if it’s more expensive. Furthermore, pick a size and firmness depending on your preferences. Finally, think about your sleeping position, it will also influence your decision.

How much does a good mattress cost?

Mattress price usually varies depending on a few factors, such as mattress type, size, height, quality of the material and durability. Today the price of a mattress can vary from $150 to $7000. However, you can find a good mattress for under $1000. The average pricing of a foam mattress is about $900 dollars, innerspring $950. These are the least expensive mattresses. However, if you can afford more expensive ones, you can consider a hybrid mattress for about $1,650, latex - about $2,000.

What size mattress should I get?

Most mattress providers offer 6 standard sizes, including Twin, Twin XL, Full/Double, Queen, King, and California King. A Twin mattress is great for children or young adults who live alone. A Twin XL mattress is great for children or single adults but not comfortable for couples. A Full/Double bed is excellent for children and couples, however, it won’t work if both people like to have more space. Queen mattresses work great for adults who like to sleep near each other. A King bed is amazing for couples who like to have some space or sleep with a pet. Finally, a California King mattress is amazing for tall people and couples who like to have space or sleep with their pets.

How long does a mattress last? When should you replace your mattress?

Mattress durability depends on the materials that were used to make it. The average lifespan of a mattress varies from 7 to 10 years. However, good quality mattresses can last even longer. It is recommended to replace your mattress every 8 years, but if it still feels great, there’s no need. If you want to buy a mattress that lasts longer than average, you should consider latex or memory foam mattresses. These can serve up to 10 or 15 years while Innerspring mattresses usually last about 7-8 years.