MyBestMattress is an independent, personal project. All the content on this website is free to use.
You can help keep the site free & unbiased by donating. Your support is highly appreciated!

Our score: 8.2

Foam pillows are often subject to controversy - some people love them, others hate ‘em. Well, today, in this Tuft and Needle pillow review, we’ll talk about a product that’s bound to change your mind for the better.

Primarily, Tuft and Needle is a mattress-selling company. However, just like many of its competitors, the brand has delved into the realm of sleep accessories, and one of the products that it offers is specialized Tuft and Needle pillows. Are they any good? Well, judging from the customer Tuft and Needle pillow review, even more than that.

TL;DR: Customer Tuft and Needle pillow review claim that the pillow is extremely good at retaining shape and conforming to the sleeper’s body. The product will mostly suit side sleepers, and is relatively cool when compared to other, similar pillows on the market.

Pros

  • Good breathability
  • Decent pricing options
  • Very moldable
  • Retains shape well

Cons

  • Possible initial odors
  • Only one firmness options

Tuft and Needle Pillow Review: PROS

One of the first things that you’ll notice while browsing through various different customer Tuft and Needle pillow reviews is that there’s a seemingly vast array of different pillow features that should be considered as “important”.

While that’s true to the extent that each individual person is going to prefer a different set of options for their pillow, there are still some things that are going to be more important than others.

For example, a study by Susan J. Gordon and her colleagues shows that latex pillows are some of the better products when it comes to reducing headaches. That’s likely more of an important feature than, say, the color of the actual pillow, right?

Tuft and Needle pillow review: a woman sleeping on a pillow.

One of the first things that you should be looking for in a pillow is whether or not it has a customizable insert. Most high-end pillow products on the market are going to allow you to alter the amount of stuffing within the pillow - by adding in or taking out some filling material, you can change the firmness level of the pillow.

Loft height is also important, especially when you’re searching for a pillow that would suit your specific sleeping position. If the loft’s too low, your neck will bend, and if the loft’s too high, it will arch up. Both scenarios are less-than-ideal in the grand scheme of things.

Do note, though, that there are exceptions - if a pillow doesn’t allow you to customize the amount of insert within it, that does not automatically mean that it’s a “bad” product - perhaps it comes in multiple firmness options, by default?

Whatever the case might be, if there’s one thing that you won’t need to worry about with the Tuft and Needle pillows, it’s shape retention.

Great at Retaining Shape

Shape retention is somewhat of an interesting topic as far as customer Tuft and Needle pillow reviews (and overall pillow reviews, in general) are concerned. While it’s one of the more important features that a pillow should possess, there doesn’t seem to be all that much attention dedicated to the topic, especially when compared to, say, sleeping positions.

So, what is shape retention, and why is it important? Basically, a pillow that retains its shape is one that will come back straight into its original form once you’ve lifted your head from it.

Pretty simple.

Some customer Tuft and Needle pillow reviews jokingly emphasize that this is great in the morning, when you’re in a rush and don’t even have the time to fluff your pillow - with a product that’s good at retaining shape, you won’t have to do that, at all!

Naturally, though, that’s not the main reason why shape retention is important.

Tuft and Needle pillow review: about the pillow.

If your pillow retains shape throughout the night, that means that your head and neck will remain in the same positions as when you’ve lied down on it. This is crucial for proper spine alignment.

The opposite of this would be when a pillow sinks - meaning, the materials inside of it tend to disperse during the night, and your head and neck tilt downwards. In this scenario, with a bent neck, your spine will have to withstand a pretty significant load, which can cause some back and shoulder pains in the morning.

Customer Tuft and Needle pillow reviews are unanimous, though - the T&N pillow is great at retaining shape, and you shouldn’t face any problems with it sinking over time. That’s mostly due to the product’s filling - adaptive foam - being as sturdy and supportive as it is.

Best for Side Sleepers

One of the more popular questions that people have reading through Tuft and Needle pillow reviews is whether or not the pillow is suitable for their sleeping position.

Seeping positions are certain specific postures in which you sleep during the night - duh. Everyone has their own, preferred sleeping position - while you may toss and turn during one of the more restless nights, you're still going to end up lying in your dominating positon.

In total, there are three main sleeping positions - side, back and stomach. Most pillow specifications revolve around these positions - companies know what’s going to suit each of the different types of sleepers best, and try to contour their products accordingly.

That being said, there are some pretty cool exceptions. And I’m not even talking about pillow types! Concerning these, one study that was performed by Jeon MY (and colleagues) and that researched how you can improve your sleep quality found that orthopedic pillows are the best option for optimal shape and temperature.

Tuft and Needle pillow review: a woman sleeping on a light pillow.

That doesn’t mean that you have to drop everything and go and buy yourself an orthopedic pillow, however - as I’ve said, there are exceptions. Some pillows might have special materials or design intricacies that make them more suitable for the different kinds of sleepers out there.

Customer Tuft and Needle pillow reviews are likely going to tell you that the T&N product is one of them.

You see, most of the company’s customers agree that the pillow is going to be best for side sleepers. This is because it’s amazing at retaining shape and molding to your body, and it has a relatively high loft that side sleepers are going to appreciate.

All of that being said, though, it’s important to note that there are quite a few back and even stomach sleepers that claim to have enjoyed their sleeping experience with the Tuft and Needle pillows! That’s very surprising, especially when it comes to stomach sleepers - these people usually need thin and firm pillows, which isn’t the case with Tuft and Needle.

Sleeps Relatively Cool

Foam pillows are not all that well-known for their breathability and cooling features - that’s a fact. Many foam pillow providers seem to struggle with coming up with different ideas of how they can make their products cool to sleep on (yes, I’m still talking about the temperature).

Tuft and Needle pillow review: the Tuft and Needle pillow.

As some customer Tuft and Needle pillow reviews note, though, this isn’t an issue regarding T&N.

Tuft and Needle’s pillow is made from adaptive foam - we’ve referenced that already. However, what I didn’t mention is the fact that the foam is infused with cooling gel and graphite. These two materials provide the product with some upper-tier cooling effects, especially when you compare the pillow with some other foam counterparts.

Lightweight Pillow

You won’t find many Tuft and Needle pillow reviews mentioning this, but I do believe it’s something that’s worth discussing, at least briefly.

Compared to some other top-tier pillows in the industry, the Tuft and Needle pillow is quite a bit lighter. It might seem like a random fact at first, but I urge you to think about it.

Imagine you’re sleeping at night, and you wake up just to adjust your pillow and go back to sleep again. Well, it’s going to be pretty simple with a light pillow, but it may prove to be a more daunting task with a heavier one. The entire ordeal might end with you having to wake up and sit up completely, which will ruin any and all coziness that you might have had.

Tuft and Needle Pillow Review: CONS

Reading through the customer Tuft and Needle pillow reviews, you’re likely going to notice that things aren’t all sunshine and rainbows - the product does have a few notable complaints garnered around it. While some customers aren’t all that fond of the Tuft and Needle pillow price, others claim the lack of customization to be the main issue.

Let’s tackle the latter first.

No Adjustable Loft / Firmness

I’ve mentioned this at the very beginning of the Tuft and Needle pillow review, but most of the top pillow providers today try to make sure that their products would have adjustable firmness settings. More often than not, that’s the ability to take out or put in extra stuffing.

Tuft and Needle pillow review: materials of the pillow.

That’s not really possible with the Tuft and Needle pillow. The product comes with a single firmness option - medium firm. It’s likely going to suit most of the different sleepers out there (especially side sleepers who don’t mind a firmer pillow), but the lack of adjustability is still noticeable.

Another thing - loft height. While adding or removing insert, you can play around with the height of the loft of a pillow. This, in turn, makes it more suitable for different sleeper types. Yet again, that’s something that’s not possible with the T&N product.

New Pillow Smell

New item smells are nothing new - everyone knows that new products tend to have a lingering odor that dissipates over time.

So… What’s the problem? Well, multiple customer Tuft and Needle pillow reviews have pointed out the fact that this pillow might take a bit more time to completely off-gass.

Is that really an issue? Most probably not. Will it be annoying if you have a sensitive sense of smell? Yup, it likely will.

Price

When it comes to pillow prices, you could look at it this way - the average price of a top-level pillow will range around $100. Nowadays, it might even be less, but that’s a pretty good general baseline to keep in mind.

I’ve mentioned earlier that there are some people who aren’t all that fond of the Tuft and Needle pillow price. Is it really that bad?

Well… No, not really:

T&N has priced their pillow at average (and even below-average!) price tags. I’ll admit, there are definitely cheaper products available. That said, though, the Tuft and Needle pillow price is far from being outrageous, especially given the quality of the product in question.

In addition to rather decent prices, if you were to purchase the Tuft and Needle pillow, you’d receive a 100-night free trial, 3-year limited warranty, and even free returns. Not a bad deal indeed!

Conclusions

Today, the sleep accessory market is literally overflowed with a vast amount of different pillows, mattresses, blankets, sheets, and so on, and so forth. For your average, everyday sleeper, it can get really confusing - if all that you want to do is purchase a new pillow and be done with it, you might find yourself in a bigger struggle than you originally intended.

It doesn’t have to be that way, however. Customer product reviews (read: Tuft and Needle pillow reviews) are there to lend you a helping hand and provide you with some quick, yet informative facts about the products that interest you.

Tuft and Needle pillow review: the tuft and Needle pillow product.

The Tuft and Needle pillow is a breathable, foam-based product that’s going to be best for side sleepers, although it might suit all of the other types of sleepers, as well.

While the pricing options of the pillow aren’t all that bad, customers should note that there might be some off-gassing during the first few nights of sleep, and that you can’t adjust the loft or firmness of the pillow.

All in all, the T&N pillow is a decent product that surely deserves a spot on the list of the top pillow products of the year. If you do decide to try the pillow out for yourself, you’ll also receive a 100-night sleep trial and a 3-year warranty.

Thanks for reading, and good luck in finding the best pillow for yourself!

Leave your honest Tuft and Needle Pillow review

Leave your genuine opinion & help thousands of people to choose the best mattress. All reviews, either positive or negative, are accepted as long as they’re honest. We do not publish biased reviews or spam. So if you want to share your experience, opinion or give advice - the scene is yours!

FAQ

Is the Tuft and Needle pillow suitable for stomach sleepers?

The Tuft and Needle pillow is going to suit side sleepers best, though some stomach sleepers do state that the product fits their wants and needs. However, if you want the best possible option, you should take a look at our list of the top pillows for stomach sleepers.

What are the pricing options for the Tuft and Needle pillow?

You could purchase the Tuft and Needle pillow for either $75 or $100, depending on the size of the pillow.

What does pillow "breathability" mean?

Whenever a pillow is "breathable", it means that either the cover, or the insert of the pillow (or both) are made in a way that doesn't obstruct airflow and keeps the pillow itself cool throughout the night.

What is the average price of a decent pillow?

While there is some debate around this topic online, the general consensus seems to be that the average price for a top-tier pillow product ranges at around the $100 mark. That said, you can definitely purchase a great pillow for much cheaper.

Should I purchase a single pillow?

While many people don't know this, you should always purchase two pillows (they can both be different, depending on your sleeping position and personal preference). The second pillow should go either between your legs or under your lower back area, so that your spine would remain perfectly aligned during the night.

Can one pillow only be suitable for a single sleeping position?

No. The same pillow can be great for all of the main sleeping positions. It all depends on the pillow's design, whether or not it has an adjustable loft and firmness level, and so on. That said, you should always double-check whether a pillow that you're opting to purchase is suitable for your sleeping position or not.