MyBestMattress is an independent, personal project. All the content on this website is free to use.
You can help keep the site free & unbiased by donating. Your support is highly appreciated!

Puffy vs WinkBeds vs Casper - Mattress Comparison At a Glance

By performing head-to-head Puffy vs WinkBeds vs Casper mattress comparison & technical product evaluation against each other, we have divided results into 8 most important groups of factors. While comparing mattresses, Puffy showed an overall score of 9.7, while WinkBeds earned 9.1. The third place goes to Casper with a score of 7.3. Another important mattress comparison factor is the customer satisfaction rating collected from real user reviews. Puffy is found to score 4.6 stars (out of 5) versus WinkBeds, which has received a 3.8 star rating. Casper is left at the third place with the customer satisfaction score of 3.5.
We have also compared both of these factors with the best-rated & leading mattress brand - Saatva - that has scored 9.8 rating in the overall score & 4.6 stars in customer satisfaction category. Check the more detailed technical analysis below.

Compare Other Mattresses

Swipe right to compare

Horizontal scroll hint
Saatva
SAATVA
Puffy
PUFFY
WinkBeds
WINKBEDS
Casper
CASPER
Saatva comparison
Puffy comparison
WinkBeds comparison
Casper comparison

Overall Score

9.8
9.7
9.1
7.3

Type

Innerspring Memory Foam Hybrid Memory Foam

Best Sleeping Position

All All All All

Verdict

Best innerspring mattress. Eco-friendly and responsive. Good for back pain & all sleeper types All-around solid mattress provider. Pricey, but worth the money. Eco-Friendly, Medium-Firm, 100-Nights Sleep Trial
Visit site
Read Review
Visit site
Read Review
Visit site
Read Review
See TOP10 Brands
Read Review

Puffy vs WinkBeds vs Casper In-depth Comparison

Here you can browse carefully gathered & aggregated data about mattresses, all in one convenient place. All the metrics are fact-checked & handpicked - no false marketing, only real evaluations. Check the Puffy mattress vs WinkBeds vs Casper in-depth comparison chart, analyze the different factors & see which mattress wins the race!

Compare Other Mattresses

Swipe right to compare

Horizontal scroll hint
Saatva
SAATVA
Puffy
PUFFY
WinkBeds
WINKBEDS
Casper
CASPER

Pros

  • Very bouncy and responsive
  • Cool (temperature AND visual-wise)
  • Top-tier edge support
  • Handcrafted in the US from ECO materials
  • Best for all type of sleepers
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Total spine pressure elimination
  • Good noise and motion isolation
  • Bouncy
  • Great temperature neutrality
  • No off-gassing
  • Made of Quality Material
  • Casper is For Every Sleeper’s Needs
  • Medium-Firm Level of Support that Works for Almost Everyone
  • 100-Nights Sleep Trial
  • Durable (Confirmed by Users' Reviews)

Cons

  • Somewhat heavy
  • Average temperature neutrality
  • 30-day break-in period
  • Relatively new company
  • Only One Firmness Option
  • Not so Great for Hot Sleepers

Value For Money

Customer Satisfaction

Standard Prices & Dimensions (without discounts)

Cali King

(72" x 84")

Cali King mattress price

$1499

Cali King mattress price

$1350

Cali King mattress price

$1849

Cali King mattress price

$1195

King

(76" x 80")

King mattress price

$1499

King mattress price

$1350

King mattress price

$1799

King mattress price

$1195

Queen

(60" x 80")

Queen mattress price

$1099

Queen mattress price

$1150

Queen mattress price

$1599

Queen mattress price

$995

Full

(53" x 75")

Full mattress price

$999

Full mattress price

$995

Full mattress price

$1299

Full mattress price

$895

Twin XL

(38" x 80")

Twin XL mattress price

$750

Twin XL mattress price

$825

Twin XL mattress price

$1149

Twin XL mattress price

$645

Twin

(38" x 75")

Twin mattress price

$600

Twin mattress price

$795

Twin mattress price

$1049

Twin mattress price

$595

Latest Coupons

All Saatva Coupons All Puffy Coupons All WinkBeds Coupons See All Coupons of Best Mattresses
Features

Firmness

6.0

|
|
|
soft
medium
firm

5.0

|
|
|
soft
medium
firm

6.0

|
|
|
soft
medium
firm

5.5

|
|
|
soft
medium
firm

Thickness (")

12 10 14.5 11

Weight (lbs)

120 72 135 71

Layer Number

4 3 3 4

Layer Materials

Saatva mattress layers
1 -
2 -
3 -
4 -
1) 1.25" TitanFlex Foam
2) 0.375" Memory Foam
3) 4" Individually Pocketed Coils
4) 7" Continuous Coils
Puffy mattress layers
1 -
2 -
3 -
1) 2" Gel memory Foam
2) 2" Transition Foam
3) 6" Support Layer
WinkBeds mattress layers
1 -
2 -
3 -
1) 2" Polyfoam/Polyurethane Foam
2) 2.5" Microcoils
3) 7.5" Individually Pocketed Coils
Casper mattress layers
1 -
2 -
3 -
4 -
1) 1.5" Latex Foam
2) 1.5" Memory Foam
3) 1.5" Polyfoam/Polyurethane Foam
4) 5" HD Polyfoam

Durability

Good Good Good Good

Edge Support

Excellent Average Average Good

Cooling

Excellent Average Good Average

Motion Isolation

Average Excellent Good Average

Noise Isolation

Good Excellent Good Good

Responsiveness

Excellent Average Good Good

Off-gassing

|
|
|
none
moderate
heavy
|
|
|
none
moderate
heavy
|
|
|
none
moderate
heavy
|
|
|
none
moderate
heavy

Bounciness

Excellent Excellent Good Average

Suitable for sex

Excellent Excellent Average Average
Shipping & Trial

Trial

180 Nights 101 Nights 120 Nights 100 Nights

Warranty

15 Year, Non-prorated Lifetime Lieftime 10 Year

Free Shipping

International Shipping

Pressure Points

Back Relief

Joint Relief

Neck Relief

Shoulder Support

Company's Info

Headquarters

Westport, Connecticut, USA Los Angeles, California, USA Greater New York Area, East Coast, USA New York, New York, United States

Year of Origin

2010 2017 2015 2013

Mattress Made In

Made in USA USA Made in USA USA Made in USA USA Made in USA USA
Quotes about the mattress

Expert Comment

Expert comment Saatva was named #1 rated best mattress of 2023 in the US. It is one of the rarer companies that sell luxurious innerspring mattresses, as opposed to all-foam... read more Aaron S. - Expert Reviewer
Expert comment Puffy is a well-designed all-foam mattress with the biggest perk - its price. According to Puffy reviews, it a high-quality mattress with amazing motion isolation and is... read more Aaron S. - Expert Reviewer
Expert comment As you might notice from the multiple customer WinkBed reviews, this innerspring mattress is a great choice for anyone that values sex and hates heat waves. WinkBed suits all... read more Aaron S. - Expert Reviewer
Expert comment Casper mattress is eco-friendly mattress designed from high-quality materials that combined together gives you the most comfortable sleep. It works great for back and side... read more Laura M. - Senior Editor

Check Official Website

Compare Other Mattresses

Puffy mattress vs WinkBeds mattress vs Casper Technical Analysis

From the in-depth Puffy vs WinkBeds vs Casper mattress comparison chart it’s clear that Puffy takes the cake when talking about Value for Money. Puffy pricing seems to be really fair compared to the materials used & overall quality of the mattress. For the best Edge Support, Puffy is the winner. Best Durability award can be given to Puffy. The most responsive mattress is Puffy. When it comes to overall technical details, Puffy surpasses WinkBeds & Casper by receiving higher ratings for some of its most important features.

When it comes to Shipping & Trials, Casper seems to offer better overall terms than Saatva & Puffy. The Puffy mattress vs WinkBeds mattress vs Casper Pressure Points analysis revealed that Puffy mattress has better support & helps more with relieving pain. After taking all of the analyzed features into account, it’s clear that Puffy is the winner of Puffy vs WinkBeds vs Casper mattress comparison!

Even though it seems like Puffy is the best in this Puffy vs WinkBeds vs Casper round, the analysis revealed that Saatva mattress would be an even better choice for you. Based on all the main features & metrics, Saatva exceeds your chosen mattresses by far - it’s one of the best-rated mattresses out there. Based on this thorough analysis, Saatva mattress is unbeatable & takes the first place among other mattresses!

Puffy vs Casper vs WinkBeds Mattress Comparison 2024

Comparison Summary

The Puffy mattress vs WinkBeds mattress vs Casper comparison revealed that Puffy beats WinkBeds & Casper in many important mattress quality fields. Nonetheless, when it comes to overall mattress comparison, Saatva takes the 1st place as the top-rated & the most suitable mattress for you.

Now, we’ve covered everything from the pros and cons of the mattress, all the way to the price and questions like “where to buy Saatva mattress?”. As it stands, you should now be able to make your mind up whether or not you would like to try this product provider out yourself.

Read Full Saatva Review

Best User Reviews of Compared Mattresses

5.0 /5.0 - Saatva Owner
2024-08-29

Saatva mattress helped my back and hip pain after first night already so couldn't ask for more. The comfiest bed, recommend!

4.8 /5.0 - Saatva Owner
2024-08-16

Prior to purchasing Saatva bed we owned expensive memory foam mattress it was sagging like crazy. my husband and i are int he higher weight group, saatva firm turned out to be much better fit for us. quite pricey but worth it.

4.9 /5.0 - Puffy Owner
2024-07-19

I did my reseach and read many reviews before switching my old mattress and have chose Puffy. Have it for 2 months now, no regrets. Pricey but worthy tho.

4.4 /5.0 - WinkBeds Owner
2024-07-03

no smell after getting it which was the problem with mattresses we purchased before. love a classic coil feeling.

Read All Saatva User Reviews

VS
Nectar
NECTAR
Puffy
PUFFY
Nectar comparison
Puffy comparison
8.4
9.7
VS
Saatva
SAATVA
Puffy
PUFFY
Saatva comparison
Puffy comparison
9.8
9.7
VS
Puffy
PUFFY
Purple
PURPLE
Puffy comparison
Purple comparison
9.7
7.9


How Is the Puffy vs WinkBeds vs Casper Comparison Done?

We search

1. We search

For the Puffy vs WinkBeds vs Casper comparison, we crawl through hundreds of user reviews, opinions, forums & groups. We thoroughly analyze all mattress specifics disclosed on multiple different sources - huge portions of data are collected daily.

We analyze  Puffy mattress vs WinkBeds mattress  vs Casper

2. We analyze

To create the most trustworthy Puffy mattress vs WinkBeds mattress vs Casper comparison, our experts aggregate & analyze the gathered data. Each mattress is evaluated by multiple different factors. The metrics are simplified and unified, making them easy to understand.

We compare  Puffy mattress vs WinkBeds mattress  vs Casper

3. We compare

The data that was gathered & analyzed in the Puffy mattress vs WinkBeds mattress vs Casper comparison is visualized in a comprehensive chart. The mattresses are put head-to-head so that the reader could easily compare all the different factors & decide quickly.

You choose

4. You choose

According to our analysis, we decide which mattress wins the Puffy vs WinkBeds vs Casper comparison. Since we only present you with real facts and not just marketing claims, the winner is decided fair & square. But it’s still up to you to choose the right mattress!

FAQ

What are the most important features in this Puffy vs WinkBeds vs Casper mattress comparison?

The main points that every mattress buyer should consider before purchasing a mattress are layers & materials used, mattress type, pricing, warranty, trials & shipping, durability & company’s reputation. All of these metrics are reviewed & measured in this Puffy mattress vs WinkBeds mattress vs Casper comparison. It’s much easier to compare multiple factors for different brands when they’re put head-to-head in our mattress comparison chart.

How can I be sure that the data compared in this Puffy vs WinkBeds vs Casper is unbiased & realistic?

Our team of expert reviewers scan the internet daily, looking for the most comprehensive & genuine sources of information. The gathered data passes through filters which make sure that there’s no false claims. The factors & evaluations presented in the mattress comparison charts are always fact-checked, so you can be sure that we don’t pay attention to marketing gimmicks - we only care about revealing real facts to our readers.

How should I use the Mattress Comparison Tool?

Simply enter mattress brands that you want to compare in the input fields at the top of the page & click “Compare Now”. You will get thorough charts of primary & very detailed mattress measures and factors. The chart has 8 different sections - pricing & dimensions, features, pressure points, company’s info, quotes, shipping and trials, etc. Browse through the online mattress comparison table & see which mattress has higher evaluation points in different fields. Mattress comparison chart will show you the winning brand, but the choice is yours!

How should I choose the most suitable mattress for me?

There are many things to consider before choosing the best mattress. You have to know the mattress type, your sleeping position, layers & materials used for the mattress, pressure relief points, durability, edge support, pricing, what kind of trial & warranty terms do they offer and so much more. It might seem overwhelming, but not when you have everything in one convenient place - the Mattress Comparison Tool. Here, you can quickly measure and choose the right mattress. Just pick the brands you want to compare & see the specifics head-to-head. Save time & effort by browsing only fact-checked metrics.

How long does a good mattress usually last?

While doing mattress comparisons, you’ll see that the mattress durability depends on the materials used. Usually, a good mattress can last up to 7 or 10 years. The premium class luxury mattresses can serve you even longer. Still, as a good practice, you should replace your mattress every 8 years. The most durable mattresses are latex & memory foam ones. They can last up to 10-15 years! So don’t forget to check the mattress type & materials in our online mattress comparison chart for better durability understanding.

What is the approximate price of a good mattress?

In our mattress price comparison chart, you’ll see that the price range varies, usually depending on the materials used & the mattress size. The common price range can be between $150 & $7000. Usually, you can find a good mattress for about $1000. Foam mattress usually cost around $900 & innerspring around $950. Talking about more expensive beds, you can find a hybrid mattress for around $1,650 & a latex one for $2,000.