Mattress pads are often overlooked. The majority of sleepers think of this bed item as “nice to have”. However, it’s way more than that.
Mattress pads are multifunctional. They not only provide you with additional softness and comfort but also protect your mattress from liquids, dirt, and other harms. Even though some sleepers purchase it together with a new mattress, its main function is to add comfort to your old bed that’s already worn off. Based on the research, older beds reduce the quality of your sleep and can increase stress-related issues.
Even though there are hundreds of products, only some of them deserve to be called “the best mattress pad”. To find these products, I’ve performed a thorough analysis of customers’ reviews and now can offer to you the best mattress pads:
- Saatva Organic Mattress Pad
- Puffy Mattress Pad
- Avocado Organic Cotton Mattress Pad/Protector
- OrganicTextiles Wool Mattress Pad
- eLuxury Bamboo Mattress Pad
Now, before running straight into each of the reviews, I want to introduce you to the most common mattress toppers and the general information about them. When you’ll have the knowledge, it will be easier to decide which is the best mattress pad for you.
Best Mattress Pad: Intro
To begin with, some of you might consider that mattress pads are the same thing as mattress toppers or protectors but there’s a huge difference.
Mattress pad, as I’ve already said, is created to breath new life into your old bed. Protector, on the other hand, is designed for the main purpose to secure your mattress from dirt, spills, and other conceivable harms. And mattress topper is aimed to add softness or firmness to your mattress.
Now, even though some mattress pads are waterproof and offer protection against spills, it’s not the main purpose that they’re created for. So, they will defend your mattress against stains better than toppers but not as good as mattress protectors.
The last major difference is the hypoallergenic qualities. Mattress pads that are hypoallergenic are not so easy to find, whereas protectors are often designed specifically for allergic people.
I believe you see the main difference between these three products now. Now, let’s move to different types of mattress pads to make it all super clear. Here they are:
- Cotton. Pads made of cotton are known for exceptional plushness. They’re designed to add additional softness to your mattress. Such pads are rarely water-resistant unless they have a special waterproof layer. However, it will provide your mattress with protection from stains. The price varies depending on cotton, it will be more expensive if organic cotton is used. Based on the mattress pad reviews, cotton pads are the most popular, and since it offers amazing breathability, you might also find that the best cooling mattress pad is made of this material.
- Latex. Such pads can add more bounciness to your mattress. They also create a layer of protection against harms, however, are not 100% waterproof as well. The price varies depending on the material - is the latex synthetic, natural, or a blend?
- Memory foam. Known for adaptive properties, the memory foam mattress pad will add additional pressure point relief to your bed. Even though they provide very little protection against liquids, it’s a great idea to purchase a memory foam pad once needed to improve the qualities of your old mattress.
- Wool. Such pads tend to be truly expensive. But there’s a reason for that. Wool is natural and provides warmth as well as breathability. However, even though wool tends to absorb moisture rapidly, it won’t protect your mattress against liquids. They’re a perfect alternative to the best heated mattress pads. One research showed that wool next to skin improved the quality of sleep in cool temperatures.
- Feather. Pads made of feathers add softness to your mattress. They’re made of geese’ or ducks’ feathers and can give you more warmth. The protection of feather pads is very limited.
Now that you’re aware of the features of different mattress pads, it’s time to find the best mattress pad for you.
Ranks #1 out of 5 Mattresses
- + Made of certified 300 thread count organic cotton
- + Super breathable
- + Adds softness and alleviates pressure points
- - Not all prefer adding plushness to mattress
Saatva's Organic mattress pad was evaluated as the best by the sleepers. It’s made of 100% certified 300 thread count organic cotton that not only adds additional softness and comfort but is also super breathable. So, that’s perfect for sleepers who experience nightly sweats.
Saatva positions themselves as respectful to the environment. That's why they use the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) certified materials that are chemical-free. So, this is definitely the best mattress pad, especially for individuals who value ecology.
Pad itself is diamond-patterned. The stitches allow the cotton to stay in place as well as to maintain the structure of the pad. The elastic band can adapt to any mattress thickness up to 16”. It also helps to maintain the pad in the right place, even if you’re having bad dreams.
What’s amazing is that you can simply wash it in the machine on gentle settings. So, it’s super simple to keep it clean and fresh.
What is Saatva Organic Mattress Pad Price?
Organic products tend to be rather expensive, especially when it’s the best mattress pad we have in mind. So, take a look into the Saatva’s Organic Mattress Pad pricing:
- Twin - $135 USD
- Twin XL - $150 USD
- Full - $165 USD
- Queen - $175 USD
- King - $195 USD
- Cal King - $195 USD
- Queen Upper-Flex - $205 USD
- King Upper-Flex - $225 USD
Note that all prices in the “best mattress pad” list are provided without discounts and at the current pricing. So, they might be slightly different by the time you’re reading this article.
As you can see, even though Saatva offers the best mattress pad, they keep prices at an optimal range. You can also try it free for 45 days and get a 1-year warranty. By the way, since Saatva offers various deals regularly, you can find each of the current offers here.
Ranks #2 out of 5 Mattresses
- + Oeko-Tex certified materials
- + Stays in place
- + Exceptional cooling
- - Not very protective
Puffy is often considered the best cooling mattress pad. And for a good reason. The pad is designed using Oeko-Tex certified materials that are completely chemical-free.
It’s made of 383 thread count cotton that is the perfect harmony between softness and breathability. What is more, the Puffy mattress pad is perfect for those who have a firm mattress and want to add some plushness without making it hot.
Box-stitching makes sure the pieces of cotton stay in place and, at the same time, give your mattress luxurious sensation, even if your bed is no longer attractive.
Moving further, the pad comes with durable stretch pockets that allow you to add it on any mattress up to 15” tall. The stretchable pockets will keep the Puffy's pad in the same place no matter how much you move.
You can wash it in the machine. Since only quality materials are used, it will stay like new after multiple washes.
How much Does the Puffy Mattress Pad Cost?
Since Puffy is made of certified and chemical-free cotton, and is often considered the best cooling pad, it does come with a price. Have a look:
- Twin - $170 USD
- Twin XL - $185 USD
- Full - $205 USD
- Queen - $225 USD
- King - $245 USD
- Cal King - $245 USD
As you can see, it’s slightly more expensive than Saatva’s pad, however, it maintains a great price-quality ratio. What’s more, you get a 101-night sleep trial and an exceptional lifetime warranty.
Ranks #3 out of 5 Mattresses
- + Luxurious feel
- + Organic certified cotton
- + Breathable 400 thread count cotton
- - Some sleepers lack puffiness
Avocado offers both pad and protector in one place. It’s made of 100% GOTS organic certified, 400 thread-count long-staple ticking cotton. Unlike the majority of other mattress pads, it not only feels but also looks luxurious.
What is more, the cotton is super breathable, soft, and absorbent. It will protect your mattress from human accidents such as stains, liquids, and dirt. Avocado doesn’t use any chemical finishes but that also means that it’s not 100% water-resistant.
Based on the mattress pad reviews, as a protector Avocado is not the best option, however, as a mattress pad, it’s definitely one of the best products out there.
The pad is super easy to clean. You can machine wash it using an eco-conscious laundry detergent. Even after multiple washes, it will maintain it’s form - diamond-stitching keeps cotton in intact.
What is Avocado Organic Cotton Mattress Pad Pricing?
Let’s move to Avocado mattress pad pricing:
- Twin - $199 USD
- Twin XL - $199 USD
- Full - $229 USD
- Queen - $249 USD
- King - $299 USD
- Cal King - $299 USD
The prices are exactly what you can expect from one of the best mattress pads. Even though it’s not the cheapest alternative, high-quality, durable materials have their value. And you can easily get it for less by taking advantage of the best deals.
Ranks #4 out of 5 Mattresses
- + 100% Premium Australian wool
- + Organic sateen cotton for cover
- + Exceptional cooling
- - Expensive
Pads made of organic wool are the perfect alternative to best heated mattress pads. So, instead of purchasing an electric product, choose the natural OrganicTextiles wool mattress pad.
This pad is filled with 100% Premium Australian Wool and uses 100% organic sateen cotton for cover. Wool works perfectly at regulating body temperature and quickly soaks moisture to provide you with a pleasant nighttime sleep. That’s why it’s also one of the best cooling mattress pads.
If your mattress is too firm, you can also use the OrganicTextiles wool mattress pad to make it softer. So, you can adjust your mattress feel without purchasing a new mattress. You can use it for all mattresses that are up to 17” tall. Elastic bands will keep it in place.
You can machine wash it on a gentle cycle, in cold water only. So, the maintenance does not require lots of effort.
What is OrganicTextiles Wool Mattress Pad Pricing?
Many sleepers evaluated OrganicTextiles product as the best mattress pad, however, it can be out of the price range for some. Take a look:
- Twin - $275 USD
- Twin XL - $296 USD
- Full - $296 USD
- Queen - 334 USD
- King - $384 USD
- Cal King - $417 USD
As you can see, the wool pad requires investment, however, to make sure you're purchasing the right product, OrganicTextiles gives you a 30-night sleep trial. Based on mattress pad reviews, it helps to make the right decision.
Ranks #5 out of 5 Mattresses
- + Breathable
- + Extra plush and silky feel
- + Invisible on mattress
- - Some sleepers are concerned about quality
eLuxury offers an exceptional product - an extra thick bamboo mattress pad that’s being used in luxurious hotels. It’s extra plush and feels silky to skin. Since bamboo fabric is super breathable, you will never sleep hot. So, if you’re looking for the best heated mattress pad, it won’t be a great choice for you.
The top of the mattress pad is made of 70% polyester and 30% rayon. It keeps the mattress design intact and prolongs the durability. The inside of the topper is filled with cluster fiber filling that manages to trap air and, this way, maintain the shape longer.
eLuxury Bamboo mattress pad provides additional pressure point relief and softens your mattress. So, it’s not great if you aim for a firmer mattress. And if you’re looking for an organic product, it won’t be the right choice.
It’s recommended to wash this pad in cold water on a gentle cycle, and dry without using heat. However, based on the best mattress pad reviews, the condition of the pad strongly decreased after washing it.
What is ELuxury Bamboo Mattress Pad Pricing?
ELuxury offers one of the cheapest mattress pads. Take a look into the pice and size options:
- Twin - $99.99 USD
- Twin XL - $99.99 USD
- Full - $114.99 USD
- Queen - $124.99 USD
- King - $139.99 USD
- Cal King - $139.99 USD
As you can see, you can spare your savings significantly by purchasing the ELuxury Bamboo mattress pad, however, maybe it’s worth adding a few dollars and getting the best mattress pad? Think about it.
Therefore, finding the best mattress pad might not be as easy as it seems, however, when you know what qualities you’re looking for, it gets way less complicated. For now, Saatva manages to offer the best mattress pad of them all.
It’s made of organic cotton, is breathable, absorbing, looks luxurious, and is super durable. If you want to improve your old mattress, then you can simply add it to the top. It fits any mattress up to 16” tall. Of course, if you’re aiming for the best experience, you should also get a mattress for your personal needs. You can find some recommended options here.
By the way, we have gathered all the special deals, so, you can discover mattresses and pads for much lower pricing.
Hopefully, I helped you to decide and you’ve managed to find the best mattress pad based on your needs.
Scientific References Quote contributed by Brittany Ferri, Occupational Therapist, CPRP
1. Bert H. Jacobson, Ali Boolani, and Doug B. Smith: 'Changes in back pain, sleep quality, and perceived stress after introduction of new bedding systems'
2. Mirim Shin, Mark Halaki, and Paul Swan: 'The effects of fabric for sleepwear and bedding on sleep at ambient temperatures of 17°C and 22°C'