MyBestMattress is an independent, personal project. All the content on this website is free to use.
You can help keep the site free & unbiased by donating. Your support is highly appreciated!

Our score: 7.8

Brooklyn Bedding is a mattress-selling company. Well, at least primarily - the brand does also offer some high-quality, luxurious pillows. In this Brooklyn Bedding pillow review, we’ll take a look at two of the company’s main products - the Brooklyn Bedding shredded foam pillow, and the Talalay latex one.

While both of these products are quite different in the way that they’re built, they do share some things in common. Rather, some benefits - both of the pillows are regarded as being top-tier products, sand we're going to talk about why that's the case.

TL;DR: Both the Brooklyn Bedding shredded foam pillow and its latex counterpart sleep cool and are very supportive. Customer Brooklyn Bedding pillow reviews note that the pillows might be difficult to clean, but the price tags are a good condolence.


  • Affordable prices
  • Good breathability and coolness
  • Best for side and back sleepers, but suitable for stomach ones, too


  • Initial odor
  • The loft might be too high for some (latex)

Brooklyn Bedding Pillow Review: PROS

In the same way you wouldn’t go out and purchase any random mattress from the first shop that you encounter, you probably wouldn’t also buy just any pillow. Each individual person is going to have their own specific preferences for what they think is the perfect pillow.

Some people are going to emphasize that cooling is the most important aspect for them. No one wants to sleep on a pillow that makes their head feel like it’s in an oven - that’s for sure. However, if you’re looking at the best pillow providers of the current year, most of the time, their products are going to have some breathability features.

Brooklyn Bedding pillow review: BB's foam pillows on a bed.

Customer Brooklyn Bedding pillow reviews will tell you that shape retention is another thing to look into. This is probably more notable within the Brooklyn Bedding Talalay latex pillow reviews - multiple studies have proven that latex is the way to go if you want to reduce headaches and instances of waking up in the middle of the night.

Shape retention, as the term implies, is the feature of a pillow that maintains its original shape even after being slept on. Pretty self-explanatory, right?

Well, yes, but here’s the best part - pillows that have good shape retention are usually very supportive. Sure, there’s always the danger to get “too supportive” and forget comfort, altogether, but it’s usually the other way around.

Well, you don’t need to worry about this when it comes to either Brooklyn Bedding shredded foam pillow or the latex one - they are both very supportive.

Both Pillows Offer Great Support

Whenever you read customer Brooklyn Bedding pillow reviews, always note that the term “support” is used to describe the pillow’s ability to keep your head and neck in a stable position throughout the night.

In addition to avoiding the formation of neck sores, supportive pillows actually have another use - they allow your spine to remain as relaxed as it can, providing that much-needed rest while you sleep.

Spine support - so what? Well, that’s actually something that many people take for granted! If you’re constantly experiencing lower back pains, and can’t seem to get a good night’s sleep for a while now, a non-supportive pillow might perfectly well be the reason for why that's the case!

Brooklyn Bedding pillow review: BB's pillow assortment.

Judging from customer Brooklyn Bedding pillow reviews, both the Talalay latex pillow and the premium shredded foam version are products that don’t have any issues with being “supportive”. But let’s take a deeper look at why that’s the case.

Latex products have always been known to provide some decent support - that’s nothing new. The fact the BB’s pillow is filled with Talalay latex only makes the product more breathable - a really good combination.

Shredded foam, however, is trickier. Some pillows are going to be very supportive, while others might fall completely flat after a few hours of lying on them. It all kind of depends on the foam in question.

The Brooklyn Bedding shredded foam pillow, though, is filled with some of the better-quality foam. This is why it remains supportive, providing proper spine alignment and neck (head) positioning.

Premium Foam Pillow - Customizable

Not to sound like a broken record, but some pillow features are always going to be more important than others. Loft height and firmness level customization will always be at the top of the priority list.

The height of a pillow loft will determine how arched or bent your neck is. Ideally, you want it to be aligned to the surface of your mattress. Firmness is somewhat the same - while most people are going to opt to go with a “softer” pillow, sinking is a thing that happens and it’s something that you should avoid at all cost, if you want to retain your lower back health.

Thankfully, though, there’s a very simple way of how you can make sure that both the height of the loft, and the firmness level of the pillow are in check with your personal needs - unzip the thing, and either add or remove some insert.

Brooklyn Bedding pillow review: the shredded foam pillow.

Simple, right? Well, no - not all that many pillows have customizable lofts and firmness levels. Multiple Brooklyn Bedding pillow reviews will tell you that this is even somewhat rare when it comes to the top-tier pillows of the industry, too.

All of that being said, you’re in luck - while the case might be different with Brooklyn Bedding Talalay latex pillow reviews, people who’ve bought the foam counterpart can be happy that they’re able to customize the product as much as they want.

Furthermore, the pillow comes overstuffed - you can then take out some of the stuffing in order to make the perfect product for yourself.

Great Cooling Features

Sleeping hot sucks. While pillows aren’t going to be the primary sleep-related object that’s going to determine whether or not you’ve gotten a heatstroke during the night (that would be the mattress or bedsheets), they are still important.

I’ve already mentioned this earlier on in the Brooklyn Bedding pillow review, but most brands out there today know the importance of sleeping cool. Whether you’d be talking about a foam pillow or a latex one (which is the case today), there should always be something that makes the pillow breathable.

More often than not, it’s the cover.

Brooklyn Bedding pillow review: organic cotton pillow cover.

As far as latex is concerned, customer Brooklyn Bedding Talalay latex pillow reviews note that the product comes equipped in a cotton pillow cover. The fact that it’s made out of cotton allows the cover to be moisture-wicking, and it eliminates heat pretty well.

As for the foam pillow, many customer Brooklyn Bedding pillow reviews note that BB’s Premium shredded foam pillow has some cooling gel infused into the pieces of the foam itself. This, in turn, makes the pillow very cool to sleep on.

All in all, it’s obvious that Brooklyn Bedding has found a method of how to keep their pillow products temperature-neutral and breathable.

Brooklyn Bedding Pillow Review: CONS

Reading through customer Brooklyn Bedding pillow reviews, it’s pretty obvious that both of the pillows in question are supportive, breathable and well-built. However, there are some things concerning these two pillows that might not be as well-thought-out as it might seem at first glance.

And I’m not talking about controversial, difficult-to-prove things such as the effectiveness of latex pillows when it comes to them alleviating neck pain (yes, that’s actually a topic that’s prone to controversy). Rather, let’s take a look at some straightforward, self-evident reasons why there might be negative Brooklyn Bedding pillow reviews online.

Latex Pillow (Not) Suitable for Stomach Sleepers?

Both of the pillows offered by BB are usually considered to be pretty suitable for all of the different kinds of sleepers. With the shredded foam pillow, that’s not surprising - if the loft is too high or low, you can always adjust it.

However, the problem arises when we start talking about and looking into the customer latex Brooklyn Bedding pillow reviews.

You see, while Brooklyn Bedding does offer a choice between a high and a low loft, these are some very umbrella-like terms. Sure, the fact that there’s an actual choice is great, but it might still not suit some of the stomach sleepers out there. The sad part here is that you won’t find out until you’ve actually purchased the pillow.

Now, granted, we've actually even named the Brooklyn Bedding latex pillow as one of the better options for stomach sleepers. So... Things don't really add up, right?

It's actually much simpler than you think.

You see, there aren't all that many stomach sleeper reviews of the latex version of the pillow that would actually complain about the loft height. Furthermore, as far as latex pillows are concerned, in general, it's actually one of the best alternatives out there.

Difficult to Clean

Pillow cleaning processes are going to be entirely dependant on the actual pillows themselves. Some pillows will be completely machine-washable, others might require spot-cleaning, and you might even encounter products that don’t need to be washed at all (apart from the covers, of course).

Customer Brooklyn Bedding pillow reviews note that both of the pillows in question (the shredded foam one, and the Talalay latex counterpart) might be a pain in the butt to clean. The covers are easy - throw them into the washing machine, and that’s it. However, the inserts are going to have to be spot-cleaned or washed by hand.

Some Initial Odor Potential

Online, you’ll find quite a few different Brooklyn Bedding pillow reviews that mention how there’s bound to be some initial odor with both of the pillows (however, it’s going to be less-noticeable with the latex one).

Brooklyn Bedding pillow review: BB's other products.

Truthfully, this might not be too big of an issue, given that the smell is bound to dissipate after a few days of sleeping on the pillow. The only situation where this might actually cause some problems is if you have a really sensitive sense of smell. Given that these pillows seem to have a stronger initial odor than usual, it’s something that’s worth keeping in mind.


Pillow prices have always been a controversial topic. Why? Well, mostly because a good, well-built pillow that’ll last you for at least a few years to come tends to cost more than people anticipate.

That being said, however, recently there have been more and more cheaper pillows flooding the market. And I’m not talking about some $10 knock-offs - what I mean is that pillow providers have seemingly managed to lower their prices for quality products.

The first product that we should take a look at in this Brooklyn Bedding pillow review is the Premium shredded foam pillow. It comes in two pricing and size options:

Such price tags are quite difficult to believe - they’re super-low, given the quality of the pillow. Next up, the Talalay latex pillow:

While the King size version of the product seems to be out of stock as of writing this article, the pillow does come in two loft size options - high and low. Yet again, for a luxury latex pillow, the price is quite impressing.

In addition to the below-average price tags, the company offers customer free shipping, 3-year warranties and a 30-night sleep trial.


With the pillow market growing and expanding at the rates that it is, there’s a big possibility to get confused really fast when trying to find the best possible pillow alternative for yourself. Oftentimes, people rush with their decisions, and end up purchasing a pillow that they soon come to regret.

This can be avoided, though. Customer Brooklyn Bedding pillow reviews are a great example of this - no matter what pillow you’re planning to purchase, there are always going to be customers that have left their feedback on the company, product or customer service. Reading these reviews, you’ll have the possibility to learn more about the product of interest.

Brooklyn Bedding pillow reviews note that both of the pillows offered by the company are going to sleep cool, and are both very breathable. While some customers might appreciate the feeling of latex, others will find that foam pillows suit them better - and both options are going to provide you with proper cooling.

Brooklyn Bedding pillow review: a man sleeping in a bed.

While the latex pillow might not be very suitable for stomach sleepers, and both of the products can be a hassle to clean, that’s quite heavily overshadowed by the pricing options.

No matter which product you choose to go with, you can bet that you’ll receive some decent deals - especially keeping in mind that we’re talking about one of the better pillow providers on the market.

All in all, I hope that this Brooklyn Bedding pillow review was useful to you. If you’re still not sure whether or not either of these two pillows would suit you, I highly encourage you to take a look at our list of the top pillows of the current year. Perhaps you’ll find something that’ll interest you there?

Thanks for reading, and good luck!

Leave your honest Brooklyn Bedding Pillow review

Leave your genuine opinion & help thousands of people to choose the best mattress. All reviews, either positive or negative, are accepted as long as they’re honest. We do not publish biased reviews or spam. So if you want to share your experience, opinion or give advice - the scene is yours!


Which of the two Brooklyn Bedding pillows is better?

The Talalay latex pillow that the company offers is going to suit people who prefer to sleep on firmer, more shape-retaining pillows. It will also suit some stomach sleepers, even though that's a contested claim. The shredded foam pillow is going to be best for side and back sleepers.

Does Brooklyn Bedding offer refunds?

Yes. After purchasing a pillow (no matter which one), you'll have 30 days to test it out and - if you don't like it for some reason - you may return the product and get a full refund.

What does pillow "breathability" mean?

Whenever a pillow is "breathable", it means that either the cover, or the insert of the pillow (or both) are made in a way that doesn't obstruct airflow and keeps the pillow itself cool throughout the night.

What is the average price of a decent pillow?

While there is some debate around this topic online, the general consensus seems to be that the average price for a top-tier pillow product ranges at around the $100 mark. That said, you can definitely purchase a great pillow for much cheaper.

Should I purchase a single pillow?

While many people don't know this, you should always purchase two pillows (they can both be different, depending on your sleeping position and personal preference). The second pillow should go either between your legs or under your lower back area, so that your spine would remain perfectly aligned during the night.

Can one pillow only be suitable for a single sleeping position?

No. The same pillow can be great for all of the main sleeping positions. It all depends on the pillow's design, whether or not it has an adjustable loft and firmness level, and so on. That said, you should always double-check whether a pillow that you're opting to purchase is suitable for your sleeping position or not.